Home » Latest Recipes » Recipe Book » Beverages and Drinks » HOT RUM TODDY — ultimate hot buttered rum recipe – Beverages and Drinks Recipes

HOT RUM TODDY — ultimate hot buttered rum recipe – Beverages and Drinks Recipes

This post may contain affiliate links.

Recipe ingredients and directions:

I started making hot buttered rum from a Trader Vic recipe 15 years ago,

and I have gradually evolved it by adding more spices, more butter, and

less rum.

The way you make a hot buttered rum is to add some "batter" to some rum,

and heat it. I like to keep a made-up batch of the batter in the fridge

in an old tub. For parties I make up a fresh batch.

Serves 12

1 lb dark brown sugar

1/2 lb salted butter

1 tsp ground nutmeg

1 tsp ground cinnamon

1 tsp ground cloves

1 tsp ground white cardamom

750 ml top-quality dark rum (a standard "fifth" bottle, 750ml, will

serve 12)

MAKING THE BATTER

1. Put all batter ingredients (everything but the rum) in a food

processor and run it until the stuff turns creamy. Fold it down once

with a rubber spatula to make sure the spices are blended in, and run

the food processor some more.

2. Scoop the mixture into a leftover container, and refrigerate. It

will keep for many months in the refrigerator, even though it contains

butter.

MAKING THE DRINKS

1. Fill a coffee mug half-full of boiling water. The easiest way to

do this is to put a mug of hot water in the microwave. If you don’t

have a microwave, then fill the mug with boiling water, pour it out,

then fill it half-full of boiling water.

2. Add 2 generous tablespoons of batter. Stir until the batter

dissolves in the hot water. I use a small wire whisk for this stirring.

3. Add 2 jiggers of the best rum you can afford. When I make this in

quantities for parties I like to use Myers Dark Rum.

One theory of hot-toddy making is that it is impossible to use too much

batter, and you should keep stirring more in until you are bored with

stirring.

Another theory of hot-toddy making is that it is impossible to use too

much rum, and that you should keep stirring in more until your friends

panic.

Category: Beverages & Drinks Recipes

About the Author

Paul the Home Cook

Paul

Home Cook

Home cook from Europe. Collected and tested recipes from cuisines around the world — in a regular kitchen, no professional gear.

About Paul →

Weekly Recipes

New recipes every week. No spam.

Did you make this recipe?

Rate it below — it helps other home cooks find the best recipes.

One response to “HOT RUM TODDY — ultimate hot buttered rum recipe – Beverages and Drinks Recipes”

  1. Shanette Kleian

    This is so good. Except we used soft salted margerine. So it only takes a minute to spoon it out after it’s Ben in the freezer. (Butter will not break down to a creamier batter like soft margerine).
    If you don’t drink alcohol you can replace the Rum with Either boiled water… Or Hot black coffee with a generous amount of batter, and top it off with a tablespoon of Homestyle Vinilla Ice cream.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *